AN ESSAY SHOULD BE THE STUDENT’S WORK.
Keep the author
in the essay.
We call on schools, universities and examination bodies to require students to write assessed essays themselves, without using generative AI to produce or substantially rewrite the work they submit as their own.
An essay should give a student space to develop an argument, work through evidence and choose how to explain an idea. We believe that this work belongs to the student. Generating an essay, a paragraph or its central analysis with an AI system and submitting it as personal work crosses that boundary.
Our request is straightforward: make independent authorship the standard for assessed essays. Give students clear instructions before they begin, explain the help that is permitted and make room for them to ask questions. Disclosure should accompany any permitted AI use; disclosure alone should not turn prohibited assistance into acceptable work.
Teachers should be able to discuss a student’s sources, drafts and reasoning. Students should have an opportunity to explain their process and respond to a concern. An automated authorship score should not, by itself, decide whether someone has broken the rules.
We ask institutions to support this standard with time for writing, useful feedback, access to learning resources and clearly agreed accessibility arrangements. The purpose is to protect students’ opportunity to practise and demonstrate their own writing.
FIVE REQUESTS FOR EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
Make independent
authorship the standard.
Keep the writing with the student.
Do not permit generative AI to create or substantially rewrite sentences, paragraphs, arguments or analysis submitted as a student’s own assessed essay.
State the rules before the assignment.
Explain permitted assistance, prohibited uses, citation expectations and any process records students should keep. Apply those requirements consistently.
Protect access to appropriate support.
Distinguish AI-generated authorship from approved accessibility tools, reference software, spelling checks and feedback that leave the student responsible for the ideas and wording.
Use a fair review process.
Consider the assignment, the student’s drafts and their explanation. Give a student a chance to respond before making a consequential decision about authorship.
Teach the process of writing.
Make space for planning, source evaluation, drafting, discussion and revision. Assess the student’s understanding as well as the finished document.
A CLEAR BOUNDARY
Support the student.
Keep their authorship.
What the petition opposes
Submitting AI-generated essays or passages as personal work; asking a system to supply the argument or analysis; or using AI to substantially rewrite a draft that is meant to demonstrate the student’s own writing.
What needs a clear agreement
Spelling and reference tools, accessibility support and feedback should be governed by explicit assignment rules. Assistance should support the student’s work without taking over its authorship.
When AI is the subject of the assignment
A teacher may explicitly ask students to examine or compare AI output. Such output should be identified and discussed as source material. It should not be presented as the student’s independently written essay.
Read the petition principles and our academic integrity note for more detail.
PUT THE REQUEST INTO WORDS.
Read it.
Keep it.
Pass it on.
Use the statement to start a conversation with your school, university or student community.
This page shares a statement. It does not collect names, email addresses or signatures.
Keep student essays human-written. A petition from Human Readers We call on schools, universities and examination bodies to require students to write assessed essays themselves, without using generative AI to produce or substantially rewrite the work they submit as their own. An essay should give a student space to develop an argument, work through evidence and choose how to explain an idea. We believe that this work belongs to the student. Generating an essay, a paragraph or its central analysis with an AI system and submitting it as personal work crosses that boundary. Our request is straightforward: make independent authorship the standard for assessed essays. Give students clear instructions before they begin, explain the help that is permitted and make room for them to ask questions. Disclosure should accompany any permitted AI use; disclosure alone should not turn prohibited assistance into acceptable work. Teachers should be able to discuss a student’s sources, drafts and reasoning. Students should have an opportunity to explain their process and respond to a concern. An automated authorship score should not, by itself, decide whether someone has broken the rules. We ask institutions to support this standard with time for writing, useful feedback, access to learning resources and clearly agreed accessibility arrangements. The purpose is to protect students’ opportunity to practise and demonstrate their own writing. WHAT WE ASK 1. Keep the writing with the student. Do not permit generative AI to create or substantially rewrite sentences, paragraphs, arguments or analysis submitted as a student’s own assessed essay. 2. State the rules before the assignment. Explain permitted assistance, prohibited uses, citation expectations and any process records students should keep. Apply those requirements consistently. 3. Protect access to appropriate support. Distinguish AI-generated authorship from approved accessibility tools, reference software, spelling checks and feedback that leave the student responsible for the ideas and wording. 4. Use a fair review process. Consider the assignment, the student’s drafts and their explanation. Give a student a chance to respond before making a consequential decision about authorship. 5. Teach the process of writing. Make space for planning, source evaluation, drafting, discussion and revision. Assess the student’s understanding as well as the finished document. THE SCOPE What the petition opposes Submitting AI-generated essays or passages as personal work; asking a system to supply the argument or analysis; or using AI to substantially rewrite a draft that is meant to demonstrate the student’s own writing. What needs a clear agreement Spelling and reference tools, accessibility support and feedback should be governed by explicit assignment rules. Assistance should support the student’s work without taking over its authorship. When AI is the subject of the assignment A teacher may explicitly ask students to examine or compare AI output. Such output should be identified and discussed as source material. It should not be presented as the student’s independently written essay. Read and share: https://humanreaders.org/petition/
FROM A POSITION TO A PRACTICE
Make the next draft
your own.
Build an argument, check the evidence and choose a useful next revision.
Explore the writing guides